(originally posted to carreview.com on 2001.07.13)
Overall Rating
5 of 5
Value Rating
5 of 5
Model/Year:
1999 LX
Summary:
In 1999, it was time to replace my wife’s old beater, a 1985 Chevy Citation with 135k miles and no AC–we were moving to Houston, so AC was a must, and this was her first new car. As we were starting the decision process, the auto show came to town and we got to sit in and bang around everything in this price class. I wouldn’t have even thought of the Protege (great job marketing this, Mazda) if we hadn’t seen it at the show. And wow, am I glad we saw it at the show!
This car is amazing for the price. The interior space, especially the back seat, is amazing for such a small car. The handling is spectacular. We’ve put 34k miles on it in two years and haven’t had a snag–but don’t listen to anecdotes on reliability: every car has some winners and some lemons. Look up the numbers on this car and you’ll see this is a reliability champ. My wife routinely gets 33+ mpg commuting (mostly highway). We’ve added a baby since we bought it and it’s perfect for the little one as well; I can’t even imagine trying to work his car seat with base in the teensy back seat of a Corolla.
The only thing I’d have done differently if this car were primarily for me and not for my wife is that I would have gotten a 5-speed or upgraded to an ES, or both, as the car lacks zip with the automatic. This bothers her a lot less than it does me.
Car & Driver rated the ES version of this car as the best small sedan they’d ever driven in 1999, and in 2000 they rated it above everything in its price class. This is no accident. Unless you really require something substantially bigger, I can’t imagine why people would spend more when the 2001 ES version of this car can be had for around $17k, pretty much loaded. Reasonable car payments are a Good Thing, and I don’t feel like I’m sacrificing. C&D said it well: “This is a car that does everything well. And it has spirit. BMW verve for less than half the price. What’s not to like?”
In fact, I like this car so much that my next car will also be a Protege, but mine will be a Protege5 with a 5-speed for the extra zip and little extra bit of hauling capacity.
No car is perfect, though, and I did list a few fairly minor complaints; those are all things Mazda could fix and it would add almost nothing to the cost of the car. It’d be nice if more other people knew what a great car this is, too.
Strengths:
Handling, reliability, interior space, fit and finish, great standard features, nice exterior styling, good price relative to closest competitor (Civic), great big trunk, comfortable seats.
Weaknesses:
Minor stuff only: crappy Mazda marketing, only one intermittent wiper setting, no trunk release on remote, windows should have darker tint, center armrest is too low and small. Not as zippy as I’d like with the automatic (buy the ES or a 5-speed, or both)
Similar Products Used:
Looked at everyting in its price class for 1999, nothing was as good. Nothing. Civic was the next closest.